Don’t you dare come any closer, I told my best friend Kathie, or I may puke on you. I drank way too much and I am still miserable since Jason left me for another man. I agreed to have a threesome with him, but I didn’t think that I would turn out to be the third wheel. It all started out so innocently when we were sharing our fantasies and this particular scenario kept recurring for both of us. I told Jason that I always thought it would be very sexy and extremely exciting if there was another man in bed with us. I figured that he would say he wanted another woman to join us and I would have readily agreed to that, but instead Jason said that he thought his friend Shane would be able to satisfy both of our needs. Wow, was that a shocker and then Jason went on to say that the exploration would help him to solidify who he is and let him understand exactly what he wants.
Jason stated that since more and more couples are starting to open up their boundaries and experiment with the male-female-male threesome, that he wanted to test his ability to share me with someone else and see if he could do it without any conflicts or aggression. Jason said that he was willing to step outside of his comfort zone and test the waters and if there were times when he was not participating, that it would be like watching a live porn show for him. Jason convinced me that he had a sincere desire to see that my sexual wishes were fulfilled, so I told him to contact his friend Shane and set everything up for a night of passion. Jason said he would invite his friend over and he assured me that I wouldn’t have to do anything if I changed my mind when he arrived. I struggled with trying to wrap my mind around the fact that I was going to be the center of attention for two men that were going to have sex with me. When the initial shock wore off, that was replaced by genuine arousal, as I contemplated the possibilities of having two men at my disposal. Before the big day, Jason asked me what I was hoping for and I told him that I just wanted to have a good time.
When Shane arrived, we all sat on the couch and sipped some wine and when Jason started kissing me, I beckoned Shane to come and sit closer to us. Shane smiled at both of us and he didn’t seem to need any further motivation as his hands were all over me, running up and down my body. Four strong hands were soon tracing their way over my butt and breasts, making me feel warm inside, as I was being overcome with pleasure, and everyone was still fully dressed. I knew that there was no backing down now and I ordered them to take me to the bed, whispering in a sexy tone. I didn’t know what was going to happen, but I was more than ready to find out. Shane and Jason, both helped me to get undressed, and I was amazed at the teamwork that they both showed being on the same page and I began to wonder if they had ever done this before.
The guys stripped and I grabbed both of them. There was something powerful about being able to hold each guy in my hands at the same time and then I had two mouths, two pairs of hands all over my body, as these two horny sexy guys were focusing entirely on me. I was surprised at how natural the whole experience felt and I kept my eyes wide open wondering what they were going to do to me next. We got into this position and Jason apologized to Shane for some incidental touching that went on and Shane told him not to worry about it, as he rather enjoyed it. Jason told Shane that he knew something like this might happen and that as long as Shane was OK with some brief genital-to-genital contact between them, that he was too.
I told both of them that if their touching each other excites them that they should go for it, as we are all here to please each other. They were all over each other once I told them to go at it and I was no longer the center of attention. They started having a good time with each other and I watched them enjoy themselves. When the night ended and Shane left, I told Jason how much I enjoyed doing this and that I hoped we would do it again. Jason smiled at me and he said that he was definitely going to do this again.
Jason became a lot less attached to his straightness as being his all-important defining characteristic after this night, and he even developed a more conscious awareness that he was heteroflexible. Jason started canceling dates with me to be with Shane and he even went as far as saying that the sex we had together was boring. I felt alone, abandoned, and hurt, as my life was turned upside down and I didn’t know what I was supposed to do. I was still crazy for him, but I felt like I wasn’t good enough for him anymore. My situation was completely hopeless, as I knew that there was no way that I could compete with another man. I should have known better, as Jason was always a huge George Michael fan and now, I am up here on this overpass looking for the courage to move on in my life.
Written for Fandango’s Story Starter #1 and for Mindlovemisery’s Menagerie Nekneeraj’s Photo Challenge #373.